You’re not someone who likes to settle — and neither is the lady in your life. So, when February 14 comes around, you do everything in your power to wow the special someone in your life with a gift that they’ll cherish forever. While flower deliveries, gourmet chocolates, and teddy bears are lauded as romantic go-tos, think outside the box this year with these unique Valentine’s Day gifts for her. This list, which can be used to find something for your girlfriend, wife, mom, or best friend, is full of thoughtful gift ideas that will definitely make her feel the love on Valentine’s Day and beyond. Some picks look and feel expensive (silk pajamas), and others are packed with romance (preserved roses), but all of these gifts will put your feelings on display, especially if you find a way to personalize them with meaningful messages, photos, or inside jokes.

If you’re still recovering from your Christmas spending, don’t worry: We’ve included tons of Valentine’s Day gifts that have a cheap price tag (starting as low as $10) that are just as memorable as more luxury finds. Most of these ideas can arrive in just two days or less thanks to Amazon Prime, but we recommend checking out our list of last-minute gift ideas just to be safe.

Go back to the beginning of your love story — the moment you first locked eyes, said “I love you,” or recited your vows— with this constellation print, available in five different sizes. Figure out the exact GPS coordinates for  your special moment, and then this Etsy maker will handle the rest.

CHEAP BUT STILL MAKES AN IMPACT

Personalized Heart Jigsaw Puzzle

Before you wrap it up, write a heartfelt message on the back of this 14-piece wooden puzzle. Then tell her to turn it over once she pieces everything together to reveal what’s really on your heart.

AN ACTIVITY THAT COUPLES CAN ENJOY TOGETHER

Monthly Date Night Subscription Box

If she’s already exhausted the entire Netflix catalogue on date nights, then let Crated with Love give her some much-needed inspiration. Each month, a themed box full of relationship-building  games and activities will be sent straight to her door.

$10, BUT ACTUALLY PRICELESS

“What I Love About You” Journal

Fill this book with sweet nothings, inside jokes, and future plans for your life together. That way, she can flip through the pages whenever she needs a reminder of just how loved she is.  

UNIQUE WAY TO GIFT FLOWERS

Monthly Bouquet Subscription

Showing up at her door with a bouquet of roses is as classic as it gets. With BloomsyBox, you can send her a fresh arrangement of long-stem roses or mixed flowers each month. Talk about the gift that keeps on giving, no?

PERFECT FOR LONG-DISTANCE COUPLES

Couples: 100 Thought Provoking Conversation Starters

Although you two never run out of things to talk about (a sign of a good relationship, yeah?), the cards in this deck will inspire thoughtful conversations that may have never happened otherwise.

A SWEET OPTION FOR YOUR GALENTINE

Actual Handwriting Bracelet

You’ve exchanged “I love yous” more times than you can count, but what if she could actually wear your heart — er, handwriting — on her sleeve? Now that’s romantic. Send a short (but sweet) handwritten phrase and this maker will turn it into a gold, rose gold, or sterling silver bracelet.